domingo, 31 de agosto de 2025

The Great Replacement: Reflections on a Controversial Concept

 



Jordi Garriga
20 July 2025   (original en castellano)

"Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth." 

Matthew 5:5

The Great Replacement exists. It is real. It is the logic of Capital. There are no racial motives, but rather economic ones. It is not a Jewish, Muslim, Masonic conspiracy, or anything like that, but something as simple as the slave trade to the great metropolis of Europe. Naturally, these slaves are not like Europeans. They don't think about vacations or unions, but rather about improving their lives and starting a family. Europeans don't have enough children and don't want to give up certain social benefits, so replacement is perhaps inevitable. The only short-term solution is closing the borders.

When mass immigration began in Spain more than 30 years ago, led by the right-wing PP, public opinion was misled about pensions. Demographic decline, they said, made the importation of labor essential and, moreover, provided a great service to these poor people by saving them from the poverty of their countries of origin. This turned out to be a lie. The money earned by immigrants either returns to their countries of origin, remains in the underground economy, or, due to very low wages, has no impact on the economy. The solution is for Spanish workers to grow old and die on the job, while young Spaniards must also emigrate and put their talents and energy at the service of other nations.

This phenomenon is not unique to Spain. Throughout the West, we are experiencing the same phenomenon of the Great Replacement, the great transformation brought about by the hegemonic ideology: globalism. And at the same time, we are witnessing a confrontation between two camps: the globalists and the patriots. Unfortunately, the patriotic camp has two major currents, both of them doomed to failure.

On the one hand, we have a large anti-immigration and patriotic party that unites the electorate and is represented everywhere: VOX. Its main flaw is that it belongs to the globalist movement and believes in abstract citizenship. For them, being Spanish means learning to speak Spanish, working, and behaving politely. This simply allows billions of human beings to become Spanish, if they so choose, by obtaining a residence permit. To achieve this, there's no need to be patriotic and to declare oneself against illegal immigration (but legal immigration in particular).

The other current is the identitarian current, which believes in the material existence of an eternal Spain, which yearns for the return of the Spain of yesteryear, the eternal Spain. It never existed: the Spain of yesteryear will not return. The Spain of the 1980s will not return, just like the Spain of the 1930s. Everything changes. Customs and everything have changed radically in 100 or 50 years. And it continues. Admiring the past is useless in politics. The Spanish empire to which they so often refer was not nostalgic. Everything it created was the most modern and advanced of its time. Romanesque, Gothic, and Baroque cathedrals, hospitals, roads, ships, arquebuses...

Today, being Spanish no longer means anything. It is a territory governed by an oligarchy, which in turn obeys a superior oligarchy. So, imagine the ridiculousness of an "independent" Catalonia...

Both patriotic movements emphasize, with a few exceptions, the dangerousness, criminality, and savagery of those who arrive from exotic lands, belonging to foreign cultures, who will necessarily create conflicts and be like wild animals among us. It is a well-crafted discourse, but one that distances us from reality. The mass migration phenomenon should not be seen as a public order problem, but as a spiritual destabilization and an identity earthquake with unpredictable consequences.

Criminals and savages are only the tip of the iceberg, but they will build nothing. The land will be conquered by those with a national vision, a population, and know how to manage resources. I mean, any territory not conquered militarily will be conquered by the population. But it will be a civilized, orderly, educated, and hard-working population...

Yes, many immigrants steal to survive, without papers, without family, etc. They steal like anyone, regardless of culture, would steal to survive. But most people stop stealing if they find a better situation. Meanwhile, it's the common people who suffer, not the politicians, bankers, etc., in their upscale neighborhoods. And since the migratory pressure doesn't stop, this situation persists, creating conflicts for which the political class alone is responsible, and which not only allows them, but encourages them.

The same goes for rape. Thousands of young adults without wives or families also have a different view of women. It is a different culture that is mentally shocking to Westerners. A respectable woman in her country of origin goes out covered up and/or accompanied. The way Western women walk down the street gives them ideas, but they are mistaken ideas. These ideas are wrong because they too are full of prejudices and stem from truly patriarchal societies where women are protected by men with no other life horizon than that permitted by society, or rather, they are dependent on their family, and only their family. Macho behavior is tolerated that would never be tolerated by natives (deep down, they are perceived as backward and in need of learning… Is this racism?).

In short, patriots of all stripes and ideological backgrounds must realize that the most neglected levers that drive history forward and are at the root of class and racial struggles are demographic pressure and technological progress. Enough of believing in the automatic and ahistorical naturalization of masses of foreigners, enough of always turning to the past, enough of believing in magical solutions.

Today, we must face reality. Indigenous Spaniards (and Europeans in general) are just one community among many in a territory that no longer belongs to them. Europe is another American-style melting pot, with multiracial and multiracist societies. It is impossible to know what Spain will look like in 100 years, but it will undoubtedly be very different from today. Therefore, we must not sit idly by, but rather work with a long-term vision, without historical or redemptive fetishism. 

 

Source: https://strategika.fr/2025/07/25/le-grand-remplacement-reflexions-sur-un-concept-polemique/ 

Nenhum comentário: